My biased listing of the scariest bad guys in pro wrestling. This is very much an indication of what I consider scary, and should not be taken as an authoritative list. Some great heels -- such as Jake the Snake -- don't make it.
5.
Jimmy Jacobs"Love doesn't save. NOTHING saves!"
Arguably, the scariest thing about Jimmy Jacobs is the disconnect between what he looks like and what he really is. Jacobs
looks like an adorable emo boy, but in fact he is a bloodthirsty hate machine. After falling head-over-heels for his manager, Lacey, Jimmy finally won her love, only to fall right off the edge of despair when he discovered that love didn't redeem him or make him feel fulfilled. Discontent with life, he formed a quasi-cult, quasi-wrestling stable, The Age of the Fall, with several like-minded individuals. Their first public performance was stringing up an unconscious Jay Briscoe and hanging him upside down over the ring so that Jimmy could stand beneath him, pontificating on his philosophy, while Briscoe's blood rained down onto him. When Lacey fell in love with another man, Jimmy attacked her several times with a metal railroad spike, and he had no problems discarding any friends or associates that failed him or had served their purpose. Jimmy Jacobs is an evil person.
Age of the fall by BadFurDay4.
Jon MoxleyNow known by his WWE slave name, Dean Ambrose, Moxley rampaged through many independent wrestling promotions from the mid-to-late 2000s. Growing up in dire poverty, with a prostitute mother and an unknown father, Moxley is deeply traumatized and appears to suffer from borderline personality disorder, swinging wildly between despair-driven epic meltdowns and a raging god complex. His articulate, creepy promos are often compared to Heath Ledger's Joker; they actually pre-date Ledger's Joker character (I've found promos dating from 2006, before
The Dark Knight, in which Moxley is indistinguishable from his more modern persona). I actually think he's scarier than Ledger's Joker, if only because the twitchy, strung-out, unpredictably violent Jon Moxley displays a vulnerability that the Joker never has. You can clearly see the neglected child beneath the persona, and he's all the scarier for it.
3.
GoldustGoldust during his debut was one of the creepiest, most "out-there" characters WWF/E has ever had, before or since. Like a lot of their heels (see: Kane), Goldust was watered down into kid-friendly comic relief, but for the first couple years of his career, he was a 6'6 wrestling tank with an unnerving ability to tap into Middle America's homophobia and terror of the unknown. The only thing scarier than an effeminate sissy to red-blooded macho dudebros is an effeminate sissy who can bodyslam you so hard you see Jesus coming for you. I really have to give props to Dustin Rhodes, who portrayed Goldust; not only is Dustin a great wrestler, I think he's one of the better actors WWF/E has ever had. If he had let on that he was uncomfortable with his gimmick, or thought it beneath him, the whole thing would've fallen flat. But because he embodied the character so utterly, you could get behind him. Dustin also came up with a couple of Goldust's most iconic moments. It was his idea to have Goldust be wearing lingere under his ring attire when Roddy Piper rips open his outfit during this match, for example. The Bizarre One, indeed.
Goldust vs. 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper - Hollywood... by ShatteredDreamsProduction2.
RavenSomeone on Youtube once said, "If there's such a thing as a cult wrestler, it would be Raven. Raven is the Rocky Horror Picture Show of wrestlers." Raven during his epic run in ECW was such a dark, nihilistic character that almost the first thing WCW did when they got a hold of him was to turn him into a
joke. Later, he and the other ECW legends would be completely wasted in the WWE. But nothing can dilute the power of his feud with Tommy Dreamer, in which they portrayed childhood friends who had a falling out over a girl and took very different paths in life. As abusive and self-centered as he was, Raven's genuine charisma won him a group of flunkies, and during one storyline, he brainwashed The Sandman's wife and children to his side. He also notoriously crucified the Sandman with barbed wire, sort of like a less violent
Passion of the Christ. The aforementioned Jimmy Jacobs and even CM Punk in his SES days owe a lot to Raven's deranged cult-leader persona.
Raven Crucifies Sandman by Spencer6191.
MankindThe incredibly cuddly Mick Foley portrayed Mankind as a raging, mask-clad psychopathic manchild with a pig-squeal voice, who delivered eerie promos on the cruelty of mankind itself, and threw his body into every match like it didn't even matter if he hurt himself, as long as he made his opponent hurt ten times worse. Undertaker threw him off the Cell, Mankind climbed back up for more. So Undertaker chokeslams him
through the Cell... and Mankind gets back up for more. Like Goldust, Mankind would be watered down into a Muppet, but for a while there he was straight-up nightmare material. While all of Mankind's promos are incredible, I have a special place in my heart for this one co-starring Goldust, in which you can almost
smell the crazy.
Goldust & Mankind Boiler Room Interview - In... by ShatteredDreamsProduction